Pepperoni
Crispy, cupped pepperoni over bubbling mozzarella. The neighborhood standard.
by the slice or whole pie
est. in the neighborhood
Pizza
Pizza
by the
Slice
New York–style pies, hand-stretched and slid into a screaming-hot oven. Fat, foldable slices cut right in front of you.
Open Mon–Fri & Sun · Greeley Mall
what we're serving
On the Menu
Slices and whole pies cut to order, hearty pasta, and ice-cold drinks worth the trip. Here's a taste of what's on the counter.
Cheese
Just dough, sauce, and a blanket of melty mozz — the one everybody keeps coming back for.
by the slice or whole pie
Fettuccine Alfredo
Ribbons of pasta in a rich, garlicky parmesan cream. Comfort in a bowl.
made to order
Spaghetti & Meatball
Spaghetti in hearty red sauce with hand-rolled meatballs and garlic bread on the side.
made to order
Photo coming soon
Cherry Lime Rickey
Cherry, fresh-squeezed lime, and plenty of fizz over ice. Sweet, tart, ice-cold.
hand-shaken
our kitchen
Fresh & Made
Fresh & Made
to Order
We stretch the dough, ladle the sauce, and slide it into a blazing oven. It comes out blistered and foldable — and we cut your slice right when you order it. Nothing sits around getting sad.
- Dough stretched fresh daily
- Straight from the hot oven
- Cut to order at the counter
we squeeze to please!
Fresh-Squeezed
Fresh-Squeezed
Lemonade
Real lemons, squeezed right on the spot — no powder, no syrup pumps. Our Lemonade Smashers are the cold, tart chaser your hot slice has been waiting for.
Squeezed daily. 🍋
meet the owner
Meet Jason
Trattoria Natoli is Jason Natoli's place — and most days he's the guy on the peel. He built it around one simple idea: real New York slices, made by hand, for the neighborhood.
Black-and-white checkered tile, a Sicilian flag on the wall, and a case full of fresh pies. Pull up a stool, grab a slice, and stay a while.
Come Say Hi
come on in
Visit Us
Hours
- Mon – Sat10:00 AM – 8:00 PM
- Sunday12:00 – 6:00 PM